The Tweed Back-end, 2016

Some Tweed beats have reported good numbers of fish in the river, this Back-end. A good analogy to a prospective guest looking to book a 5* hotel before a lesser rated hotel, if given the same price, was made by a very experienced Bottom Tweed proprietor; i.e. the fact that the best holding water on the river is holding fish doesn't mean that the rest of the river is. Surely a sign of good numbers of fish in the river would be the lesser water being occupied by fish who couldn't find available lies in the better holding water. From my experience of the river, this Autumn, this is not the case, with many pools seemingly lying empty in late October and throughout November.

Rods have tried to put some figures on the situation but, as has been heavily covered following the Government's categorisation of rivers, catch returns are a pretty speculative way of estimating runs and their timing; however, if we're going to do so, the best we'll get is the top graph of this, courtesy of Fishpal:

FishPal - Scotland - Tweed - Season So Far

Essentially, no noticeable change apart from significant numbers of fish that would normally run from August onwards just not showing up.

The one thing I'd add to this, to qualify the depressing effect of looking at this graph, is that we've still had lots of rods (including me this year) out on the river in October and November who didn't fish it as hard or at all in June or July. If greater numbers of fish are now running the Tweed in the Summer than normal, as was noticeable this season on the Tyne and Dee, then perhaps that will take time to become apparent in catch returns. You'd expect a few more to have been caught in June or July this year, though, if this was the case. I don't recall reports of large numbers of fish in the river then either.

Subjectively, and if we're basing things on catches, I got two Tweed fish this year and they were caught in May and June, respectively, although they were both springers. A bit of Summer fishing on usually un-fished water might be interesting next year. I've also heard suggestions that there should be experimental close-season fishing in December and January to see what comes up then.

Maybe the fish that apparently didn't show up when requested in October and November will show up next Spring (I think we said that last year); Or maybe they just ran the Thurso and Helmsdale because they couldn't be bothered swimming to the Tweed as their feeding grounds are getting further away; Or maybe they just got hoovered up by some fishermen somewhere who worked out where the back end run goes. 

Further speculation is available upon request.

A 9lber going back at Middle Pavilion in June.

Sunderland Hall, Tweed (24 October 2016)

Sunderland Hall is a favourite of mine and I tend to have a few days, or at least, sessions there each season. Amongst the plus points are the very reasonable rod prices earlier in the season (Spring and Summer) and also the beat's versatility, as it has Upper Tweed and Ettrick fishing, plus the famous Meetings Pool at the bottom of the beat. This makes it an ideal venue for an evening escape from the office between May and July, while the days are longer. There are usually a good number of fish holding in the Meetings from mid-April until early June and in May and June the fastest running Spring fish will run the Ettrick, given water. Indeed, in May I managed a 16lbs springer from the Meetings which I was pretty pleased with.

One from May - great fight

In October, though, the Upper Tweed pools get the most attention and these were the focus of my most recent, unfortunately unproductive, day on the beat. There were 6 inches on the gauge at Peebles on the day and so, despite temperatures of only 2 celsius overnight, I made an early start in Black Strand (also referred to as 'The Birches') , a locally-famous holding pool in front of Sunderland Hall itself. Nothing was showing and so I only covered the top half of the long pool before moving on.

Black Strand

At the top of the beat, the Howden Pool is the main pool, although there used to be a good stream at an island below this. Readers who haven't visited Sunderland Hall or Fairnilee yet this season, but who are familiar with the beats, will be disappointed to hear that this stream has changed significantly  since last season and the stream from Howden down the left bank is far smaller than before and it looks more probably that fish run the right bank channel instead now. Some good fishing has been lost, if this is the case.

Howden itself has a more pronounced stream and flow in low water than before. This follows the right bank and did feel very 'fishy'. Again, nothing showing.

Howden Pool

Next up is Arres' Putt, a high water pool with a fast but shallow run at the top. Another rod on the beat fishing below me managed to hook and land a fish downstream, between Arres' Putt and the Needlehall Boat Pool while I was in Arres' Putt.

Arres' Putt (self-proclaimed, but I think this is a great photo of Upper Tweed-dale in Autumn!)

A fish for the rod downstream

I then headed back to the hut at the foot of Black Strand for a coffee and some food, before having a run through the Meetings and the Ettrick pools, Alder and The Bushes. I was fishing a floating line with an integrated intermediate tip and was using fly choice to control the depth thereafter. The slower high water pools on the Upper Tweed stretch, I fished with a small aluminium tube Black Snaelda, which looked the part. For the stronger flows in the Meetings, Alder and Bushes, I put on a tungsten Red Frances (having given up hope of there being anything fresh around!). I saw a stale grilse in the Meetings, but nothing more.

The Meetings

Alder Pool - very low but great fly water

Interestingly, the Council's works on the Old Tweed Bridge, long since replaced by a road crossing over the Meetings, seem to be improving the look of the Bridge Pool downstream. There were always lies here, but not much of a pool; now - unless the works change it again - a stronger flow carries further through the pool and increases the relevance of a croy on the Sunderland Hall bank. This lie currently looks very fishy and so it'll be interesting to see what comes out of here in the next few seasons, once the pool settles down again.

The Council's works on the Old Tweed Bridge

Later, I had a run through Needlehall Boat Pool (which was extremely low) with a big dressed Silver Stoat, Doocote (in-between Black Strand and the Meetings) with a Snaelda in Willie Gunn colours and a full run through Black Strand with a Junction Shrimp tube, pretty much in the dark.

 Needlehall Boat Pool

And again, from near the tail of the pool

Doocote

It's been a pretty disappointing Autumn, all round, and so there's no need for me to elaborate really. Hopefully, those with late Autumn rods and trips booked enjoy some sport even if it's with stale/old fish and a bonus would be a bit of water and some cleaner fish showing up thereafter.

A shame to blank, but Sunderland Hall is a great place to fish.